#713
Title: The Medicine Cabinet of Curiosities: An Unconventional Compendium of Health Facts and Oddities, from Asthmatic Mice to Plants that Can Kill
Author: Nick Bakalar
Publisher: Times Books
Year: 2009
240 pages
There was nothing wrong with this, and I mean the 2 stars in my Goodreads review in the Goodreads sense of "it was ok." However, it seemed more desultory than its brevity could accommodate and still seem complete, even in the "a little of this, a little of that" style.
I didn't learn much that I didn't already know, so I may be the wrong audience. Probably people who don't work in in medical/allied health professions would find it a more engaging and gripping reading experience. The information presented about which I have professional knowledge was generally correct, and in some cases I could identify the source material without checking the notes.
Saturday, November 12, 2011
Saturday, November 5, 2011
Bonk: The Curious Coupling of Science and Sex
#712
Title: Bonk: The Curious Coupling of Science and Sex
Author: Mary Roach
Publisher: W. W. Norton
Year: 2008
319 pages
Roach is an entertaining writer, and I especially admire a book on sex that has a footnote on presidential running mates. In Bonk, she's more hands-on than you'd expect, sometimes astonishingly so. She's sort of the George Plimpton of sexology.
I'd have given the book 4 stars were it not for the last chapter. There, she seems to breezily excuse Masters and Johnson's instructions for conversion therapy (same-sex to other-sex orientation) without much acknowledgement of how cruel this practice was (and is), or even an adequate exploration of its lack of efficacy. The chapter could have ended the book with a cautionary tale about how professional or cultural ideas about healthy sexuality don't always match the data. Instead, there's a blip about homosexuality and its mis-treatment, the end. I expect better of Roach and her editors.
Title: Bonk: The Curious Coupling of Science and Sex
Author: Mary Roach
Publisher: W. W. Norton
Year: 2008
319 pages
Roach is an entertaining writer, and I especially admire a book on sex that has a footnote on presidential running mates. In Bonk, she's more hands-on than you'd expect, sometimes astonishingly so. She's sort of the George Plimpton of sexology.
I'd have given the book 4 stars were it not for the last chapter. There, she seems to breezily excuse Masters and Johnson's instructions for conversion therapy (same-sex to other-sex orientation) without much acknowledgement of how cruel this practice was (and is), or even an adequate exploration of its lack of efficacy. The chapter could have ended the book with a cautionary tale about how professional or cultural ideas about healthy sexuality don't always match the data. Instead, there's a blip about homosexuality and its mis-treatment, the end. I expect better of Roach and her editors.
Paradise Lost
#711
Title: Paradise Lost
Author: John Milton
Publisher: Blackstone Audio
Year: 1667/1984
276 pages
Audiobook.
A good reader (Frederick Davidson) on this edition. The blank verse resonates and emphasizes without overpowering, and he does a good job with both rhymes and enjambment. This exegesis of Genesis relies fairly heavily on the Greek and Roman pantheons for symbolism and plot points. It's interesting to see how much more psychological this is than that other stalwart of Christian allegory, The Pilgrim's Progress.There is also more imagery, more shown than told, and more theological argument in the manner that we will later see in de Sade's The 120 Days of Sodom. Eve is weak-willed, while Adam is just a darned nice guy. They feed and angel lunch and hear its expositions.
Title: Paradise Lost
Author: John Milton
Publisher: Blackstone Audio
Year: 1667/1984
276 pages
Audiobook.
A good reader (Frederick Davidson) on this edition. The blank verse resonates and emphasizes without overpowering, and he does a good job with both rhymes and enjambment. This exegesis of Genesis relies fairly heavily on the Greek and Roman pantheons for symbolism and plot points. It's interesting to see how much more psychological this is than that other stalwart of Christian allegory, The Pilgrim's Progress.There is also more imagery, more shown than told, and more theological argument in the manner that we will later see in de Sade's The 120 Days of Sodom. Eve is weak-willed, while Adam is just a darned nice guy. They feed and angel lunch and hear its expositions.
Ship Breaker
#710
Title: Ship Breaker
Author: Paolo Bacigalupi
Publisher: Little, Brown
Year: 2010
336 pages
Audiobook.
Middle- to young adult novel with a pretty straightforward plot, post-apocalyptic but not as dystopian as The Windup Girl. The worldbuilding is pretty good, though the language is less rich (and less grim) than in his adult works. I try hard to picture the half-men as Daniel Lee's Manimals,
but usually fail and imagine something like
McGruff the Crime Dog.
Title: Ship Breaker
Author: Paolo Bacigalupi
Publisher: Little, Brown
Year: 2010
336 pages
Audiobook.
Middle- to young adult novel with a pretty straightforward plot, post-apocalyptic but not as dystopian as The Windup Girl. The worldbuilding is pretty good, though the language is less rich (and less grim) than in his adult works. I try hard to picture the half-men as Daniel Lee's Manimals,


Bright-sided: How the Relentless Promotion of Positive Thinking Has Undermined America
#709
Title: Bright-sided: How the Relentless Promotion of Positive Thinking Has Undermined America
Author: Barbara Ehrenreich
Publisher: Renaissance Press
Year: 2009
256 pages
Audiobook.
Overbroad strokes and a sour attitude no matter what render this one of Ehrenreich's worse showings. In her contempt for the positive psychology movement, she sloppily confounds a varity of professional and pop practices, and seems to ignore the vast world of cognitive psychotherapy, which is nothing if not tediously data-rich. Ehrenreich (and to be fair, some of those she derides) seems to think the goal of cognitive or positive intervention is to live longer. It's not. What some studies do show is not gains in longevity, but a better self-reported quality of life. Ehrenreich might see this as a way to coax people to go gently into that good night, but that isn't how I've experienced it as a therapist or informed consumer. She chooses really outlandish, stupid examples without identifying them as extreme, and she ignores the huge history of stupid practices in the name of religion, vilifying psychology as if it did not derive from and in many ways reflect the field of philosophy.
I can identify with her indignation expressed in the breast cancer chapter, and found her discussion of Calvanism interesting. The others are often distorted and bitter rather than funny.
Ehrenreich's Marxism is best when she sticks to her critique of capitalism, rather than, as in Nickel And Dimed: On (Not) Getting by in America, when she devolves to snapping at white women for, she reports, having more pubic hair in their bathrooms. Bright Sided may be my last Ehrenreich.
Title: Bright-sided: How the Relentless Promotion of Positive Thinking Has Undermined America
Author: Barbara Ehrenreich
Publisher: Renaissance Press
Year: 2009
256 pages
Audiobook.
Overbroad strokes and a sour attitude no matter what render this one of Ehrenreich's worse showings. In her contempt for the positive psychology movement, she sloppily confounds a varity of professional and pop practices, and seems to ignore the vast world of cognitive psychotherapy, which is nothing if not tediously data-rich. Ehrenreich (and to be fair, some of those she derides) seems to think the goal of cognitive or positive intervention is to live longer. It's not. What some studies do show is not gains in longevity, but a better self-reported quality of life. Ehrenreich might see this as a way to coax people to go gently into that good night, but that isn't how I've experienced it as a therapist or informed consumer. She chooses really outlandish, stupid examples without identifying them as extreme, and she ignores the huge history of stupid practices in the name of religion, vilifying psychology as if it did not derive from and in many ways reflect the field of philosophy.
I can identify with her indignation expressed in the breast cancer chapter, and found her discussion of Calvanism interesting. The others are often distorted and bitter rather than funny.
Ehrenreich's Marxism is best when she sticks to her critique of capitalism, rather than, as in Nickel And Dimed: On (Not) Getting by in America, when she devolves to snapping at white women for, she reports, having more pubic hair in their bathrooms. Bright Sided may be my last Ehrenreich.
The Curse of the Giant Tortoise: Tragedies, Crimes, and Mysteries in the Galapagos Islands (6th Ed.)
#708
Title: The Curse of the Giant Tortoise: Tragedies, Crimes, and Mysteries in the Galapagos Islands (6th Ed.)
Author: Octavio Latorre
Publisher: National Cultural Fund
Year: 1997
Country: Ecuador
243 pages
Ecuador.
A poorly-organized, poorly-translated hidtory of Galapagos. It often crosses into incoherence and doesn't seem to have a point other than to describe a series of disasters that, for a reader without other references and resources, are here rendered unintelligible.
Title: The Curse of the Giant Tortoise: Tragedies, Crimes, and Mysteries in the Galapagos Islands (6th Ed.)
Author: Octavio Latorre
Publisher: National Cultural Fund
Year: 1997
Country: Ecuador
243 pages
Ecuador.
A poorly-organized, poorly-translated hidtory of Galapagos. It often crosses into incoherence and doesn't seem to have a point other than to describe a series of disasters that, for a reader without other references and resources, are here rendered unintelligible.
[Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH]
#707
[Title: Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH]
Author: Robert C. O'Brien
Publisher: Aladdin Books
Year: 1971/1986
240 pages
BEFORE:
The serendipitous and simultaneous purchase of Rat Girl: A Memoir and Rat Island: Predators in Paradise and the World's Greatest Wildlife Rescue at the National Discount Rituals to Mark the Death of Borders was neither unremarked (by others) nor uncelebrated (alas, by me alone). I realized that I had other rat books at home, enough for a thematic rat shelf. Zinsser's Rats, Lice, and History: Being a Study in Biography, Which, After Twelve Preliminary Chapters Indispensable for the Preparation of the Lay Reader, Deals With the Life History of Typhus Fever, Sullivan's Rats: Observations on the History and Habitat of the City's Most Unwanted Inhabitants, and Guthrie's Even the Rat Was White: A Historical View of Psychology (Allyn & Bacon Classics Edition), Second Edition would be nicely complemented by Hersh and Stolzenburg. I am the type of person who rearranges some of the shelves to see if you are paying attention: Less Than Zero to Ten Thousand Light-Years From Home. The Sound and the Fury, The Red and the Black, The Cook and the Carpenter. Organization by spectrum. Spines depicting faces. I'm like the Kliban cartoon captioned "Just give Alice some pencils and she will stay busy for hours."
In the night I bolted up in a cold sweat. It was actually a hot sweat, but the room was cold. I cried out, but using my inside inside voice, "What about Mrs. Frisby?!" I had read Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH, twice. Surely I had a copy. Where else would I have read it? Not at a friend's house. Let's face it, my friends have kids who move right from Heather Has Two Mommies to Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal. They eschew the Frisbys and The Borrowers and Caddie Woodlawn. I, too, had skipped directly from Little House in the Big Woods to Gods, Graves and Scholars: The Story of Archaeology and History Begins at Sumer: Thirty-Nine "Firsts" in Recorded History. In fact, I lost points on an IQ test in high school when I answered the question "Who is the god or goddess of dreams?" with "Geshtinana, the divine poetess and dream interpreter." Apparently when your guidance counselor answers "In which mythology?" with "Any," she doesn't mean Sumerian. I'd have known the correct answer if those Percy Jackson books had been published, but they were decades in the future. The point is, I skipped most children's and middle readers' books, returning to them only as an adult.
I have a hard time with library books, too. There's something about a library book that makes me want to eat it rather than read it. I don't like the time pressure. Sometimes a book needs to deliquesce on my shelf for 3 or 4 years before it is sufficiently ripe. So where had the copy of Mrs. Frisby I mostly undoubtedly had had gone to?
I don't know, and I don't care. I picked up a used copy for $2 today. I will re-read it soon. At that time, my review will follow this exposition. My rat shelf is sufficient until I acquire a copy of Doctor Rat, which I began but never finished when I was 15 and worked at a library.
AFTER:
As a child, I was troubled by the lack of verisimilitude in Stuart Little. It wasn't the invisible car that bothered me, but the idea that a human could give birth to a mouse and even notice. I was aware, even as a tot, on account of my mad reading skillz, that baby mice were born in littlers, not singly, and that a litter of mousie pups would fit in a spoon. I merely mention this to demonstrate that I am a discerning reader who can suspend my disbelief when warranted. I was willing to believe that good commie rats can form an anarcho-syndicalist collective and live off the land, while bad capitalist rats get zapped by their own electricity. Or at least, that is how I read the moral.
[Title: Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH]
Author: Robert C. O'Brien
Publisher: Aladdin Books
Year: 1971/1986
240 pages
BEFORE:
The serendipitous and simultaneous purchase of Rat Girl: A Memoir and Rat Island: Predators in Paradise and the World's Greatest Wildlife Rescue at the National Discount Rituals to Mark the Death of Borders was neither unremarked (by others) nor uncelebrated (alas, by me alone). I realized that I had other rat books at home, enough for a thematic rat shelf. Zinsser's Rats, Lice, and History: Being a Study in Biography, Which, After Twelve Preliminary Chapters Indispensable for the Preparation of the Lay Reader, Deals With the Life History of Typhus Fever, Sullivan's Rats: Observations on the History and Habitat of the City's Most Unwanted Inhabitants, and Guthrie's Even the Rat Was White: A Historical View of Psychology (Allyn & Bacon Classics Edition), Second Edition would be nicely complemented by Hersh and Stolzenburg. I am the type of person who rearranges some of the shelves to see if you are paying attention: Less Than Zero to Ten Thousand Light-Years From Home. The Sound and the Fury, The Red and the Black, The Cook and the Carpenter. Organization by spectrum. Spines depicting faces. I'm like the Kliban cartoon captioned "Just give Alice some pencils and she will stay busy for hours."
In the night I bolted up in a cold sweat. It was actually a hot sweat, but the room was cold. I cried out, but using my inside inside voice, "What about Mrs. Frisby?!" I had read Mrs. Frisby and the Rats of NIMH, twice. Surely I had a copy. Where else would I have read it? Not at a friend's house. Let's face it, my friends have kids who move right from Heather Has Two Mommies to Fast Food Nation: The Dark Side of the All-American Meal. They eschew the Frisbys and The Borrowers and Caddie Woodlawn. I, too, had skipped directly from Little House in the Big Woods to Gods, Graves and Scholars: The Story of Archaeology and History Begins at Sumer: Thirty-Nine "Firsts" in Recorded History. In fact, I lost points on an IQ test in high school when I answered the question "Who is the god or goddess of dreams?" with "Geshtinana, the divine poetess and dream interpreter." Apparently when your guidance counselor answers "In which mythology?" with "Any," she doesn't mean Sumerian. I'd have known the correct answer if those Percy Jackson books had been published, but they were decades in the future. The point is, I skipped most children's and middle readers' books, returning to them only as an adult.
I have a hard time with library books, too. There's something about a library book that makes me want to eat it rather than read it. I don't like the time pressure. Sometimes a book needs to deliquesce on my shelf for 3 or 4 years before it is sufficiently ripe. So where had the copy of Mrs. Frisby I mostly undoubtedly had had gone to?
I don't know, and I don't care. I picked up a used copy for $2 today. I will re-read it soon. At that time, my review will follow this exposition. My rat shelf is sufficient until I acquire a copy of Doctor Rat, which I began but never finished when I was 15 and worked at a library.
AFTER:
As a child, I was troubled by the lack of verisimilitude in Stuart Little. It wasn't the invisible car that bothered me, but the idea that a human could give birth to a mouse and even notice. I was aware, even as a tot, on account of my mad reading skillz, that baby mice were born in littlers, not singly, and that a litter of mousie pups would fit in a spoon. I merely mention this to demonstrate that I am a discerning reader who can suspend my disbelief when warranted. I was willing to believe that good commie rats can form an anarcho-syndicalist collective and live off the land, while bad capitalist rats get zapped by their own electricity. Or at least, that is how I read the moral.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)